Transwell Assays: Pros, Cons, and Alternatives

Post author By Marco Bedolla
Post date February 23, 2024

Transwell assays are a mainstay in cell biology research and are instrumental in studying cellular migration and cell invasion.

A permeable membrane simulates a cellular barrier. If cells migrate through it then these can be stained, for instance with crystal violet, and kept at room temperature. This will be in a 24-well plate. The membrane then needs to be cleaned with distilled water before the migratory cells can be calculated.

With that completed, an assessment can be made about cell fixation compared to how many cells have migrated. Through this process, transwell assays can provide insights into the mechanisms of cancer cells and their metastasis. It can also offer an understanding of tissue repair and cellular communication.

This article provides an in-depth analysis of transwell assays, examining their advantages, limitations, and exploring alternative methodologies.

Advantages of Transwell Assays

Mimicking In Vivo Conditions: Transwell assays are esteemed for their ability to replicate aspects of the in vivo environment. The porous membrane serves as a physical barrier. This is akin to the extracellular matrix or endothelial linings in the body. It allows researchers to study cell migration and invasion in a context that closely resembles physiological conditions.
Versatility and Adaptability: It is possible to adapt cell assays to a number of cell types and experimental conditions. This will enable researchers to tailor the transwell assay to specific research questions. Modifications can provide tailored environments suitable for diverse cell types and studies. Examples include coating the membrane with different extracellular matrix proteins or adjusting pore size.
Quantitative and Qualitative Data: Transwell assays provide both quantitative and qualitative insights. Researchers can quantify migrated or invaded cells using colorimetric assays. They can also analyze cell morphology and interactions using microscopic techniques, such as the use of an inverted microscope.

Limitations of Transwell Assays

Over-Simplification of the In Vivo Environment: Despite their ability to mimic certain aspects of the in vivo environment, transwell assays lack the complexity of living organisms. They do not account for the three-dimensional architecture, dynamic biochemical gradients, or cell-cell interactions present in vivo.
Potential for Artifacts: The artificial nature of the membrane and assay conditions can sometimes lead to non-physiological cell behavior. This raises concerns about the interpretation and relevance of the results.
Limited Accessibility to Advanced Imaging Techniques: The physical structure of transwell plates can hinder the use of certain high-resolution imaging techniques. Without this technique, its abilities are restricted to observing cellular processes in real time.
Standardization Issues: Variability in membrane properties, pore sizes, and coatings can lead to inconsistencies. These can be across experiments and laboratories and potentially affect the reproducibility of the results.

Alternatives to Transwell Assays

3D Cell Culture Models: Three-dimensional cultures provide a more realistic representation of the in vivo environment. Examples include spheroids and organoids. These models allow for the study of cell migration and invasion within a three-dimensional matrix. Therefore, they can offer insights into the spatial and mechanical aspects of these processes.
Microfluidic Devices: Microfluidics allows for the creation of precise and dynamic cellular microenvironments. These devices can simulate blood flow, create chemical gradients, and facilitate real-time imaging. Therefore, they can offer a more nuanced understanding of cellular behavior.
In Vivo Models: While invasion assays do exist, animal models, though ethically and practically more complex, provide a comprehensive context for studying cell migration and invasion. These models account for systemic factors like immune response and vascular dynamics, which are challenging to replicate in vitro. A matrigel coated environment can also be beneficial if you are trying to create in vivo conditions for model creation.
Computational Modeling: Advanced computational models can simulate cellular processes, offering theoretical insights that complement empirical findings. These models can predict cell behavior under various conditions, thus guiding experimental design and interpretation.

Platypus Technologies Can Support Your Research

Transwell migration assays have been a cornerstone in cell biology research. There have been extensive applications of transwell assays because of:

Their ability to model aspects of the in vivo environment
Their versatility
Their capacity for both quantitative and qualitative analysis.

However, the limitations of transwell assays necessitate careful consideration. This includes the oversimplification of the in vivo environment and potential for artifacts. Sometimes it can be better to use alternative methods instead of transwell migration assays. The selection of an appropriate model should be guided by the specific research question, the desired level of biological complexity, and practical considerations.

Future advancements in cell culture technology and imaging techniques are expected to enhance the fidelity and applicability of in vitro models, potentially bridging the gap between in vitro assays and in vivo realities.

While transwell assays offer valuable insights into cell migration and invasion, their limitations underscore the importance of selecting the most appropriate assay for your specific research needs. Balancing the simplicity and convenience of traditional assays with the complexity and realism of more advanced models is crucial.

For researchers looking to delve deeper into the realm of cell migration studies or transwell assays, exploring innovative solutions and cutting-edge technologies is key.

Whether you are looking into more detail about transwell inserts or you want to refine your assay process, Platypus Technologies, with its commitment to advancing scientific research, invites you to discover our range of sophisticated tools and assays. These are designed to enhance your research capabilities.

Our website can help you learn about cell migration assays. Explore our offerings and see how we can support your scientific endeavors with our state-of-the-art solutions. These will be tailored to your research requirements. Get ready to embrace the future of transwell assays and cell migration studies with Platypus Tech.

Learn More about Oris Cell Migration Assays.

References

Deweerd E, Gourd C, Hoffman-Kim D, Li G, Livi L. Genomic and morphological changes of neuroblastoma cells in response to three-dimensional matrices. Tissue Engineering. 2007;13(5):1035-1047. doi: 10.1089/ten.2006.0251.
Chung M, Jeon N, Kim S, Lee H. Engineering of functional, perfusable 3D microvascular networks on a chip. Lab Chip. 2013;13(8):1489-1500. doi: 10.1039/c3lc41320a.
Katt M, Placone A, Searson P, Wong A, Xu Z. In Vitro Tumor Models: Advantages, Disadvantages, Variables and Selecting the Right Platform. Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology. 2016;4(12). doi: 10.3389/fbioe.2016.00012.
Breslin S, O’Driscoll L. Three-dimensional cell culture: the missing link in drug discovery. Drug Discovery Today. 2013;18(5-6):240-249. doi: 10.1016/j.drudis.2012.10.003.